Red, Orange, Green, and Yellow Bell Peppers stacked

Choosing Bell Peppers by Color and Flavor

Bell peppers do not all taste the same. Green peppers have a stronger, slightly bitter pepper flavor, while red peppers are sweeter. Yellow and orange peppers are generally milder and sweeter than green, which means the color you choose can change the flavor of a skillet dinner, fajitas, stuffed peppers, roasted vegetables, or even a salad.

The differences are simple enough to remember, and knowing them makes it easier to choose the pepper that fits what you are cooking.

Green Bell Peppers Have More Bite

Green bell peppers are picked before they fully ripen, which is why they taste less sweet than the other colors. That stronger pepper flavor is especially good with ground beef, sausage, onions, tomatoes, and bold seasonings because it is still noticeable after cooking.

They are a natural choice for stuffed peppers, fajitas, sausage and peppers, pizza, and skillet meals. If you like a pepper that still tastes distinctly like pepper once it is cooked, green is usually the place to start.

Red Bell Peppers Bring More Sweetness

As bell peppers ripen, they become sweeter. Red peppers have much less of the sharp flavor you get from green ones, and cooking brings out even more of their sweetness.

That makes red peppers especially good with chicken, pork, tomatoes, beans, pasta, and roasted vegetables. Their sweetness also balances ingredients with more bite, such as chile, vinegar, mustard, or a salty cheese.

Yellow and Orange Peppers Are Milder

Yellow and orange peppers are sweet and mild without quite as much sweetness as a fully ripe red pepper. They are good raw in salads and sandwiches, and when sautéed or roasted they soften while becoming a little sweeter.

They are a good choice when you want less of the sharper green-pepper flavor but do not want as much sweetness as red brings. Mixing them with other colors also gives a skillet or roasting pan more color, especially once the edges begin to brown.

Sometimes Two Colors Are Better Than One

A green and a red pepper make a particularly good pair in skillet dinners. The green gives you the stronger pepper flavor, while the red adds sweetness. You can taste the difference even when both are cooked with the same meat, rice, tomatoes, and seasoning.

That combination works especially well in taco-style rice skillets, fajitas, and sausage-and-pepper dishes. Our Shawhan Farms Beau’s Original Taco Seasoning pairs well with both, letting the peppers bring two different flavors to the same dish.

What About Raw Peppers?

The same flavor differences show up when peppers are eaten raw. Green peppers are crisp and more pronounced, which can be good with creamy dips or in a chopped salad with plenty of other ingredients. Red, yellow, and orange peppers are sweeter and often easier to snack on by themselves.

For sandwiches and wraps, choose according to what else is inside. A sweeter pepper is good with salty cheese or deli meat, while green pepper gives a stronger contrast to milder fillings.

Use What You Like

There is no wrong bell pepper for most recipes. If you prefer the stronger flavor of green peppers, use them. If your family always picks the red ones out of a vegetable tray first, buy red.

Once you know the basic differences, it is easy to decideKitchen whether a dish would benefit from more bite, more sweetness, or a little of both.

Shop the seasonings

Shawhan Farms: Grounded in Quality

Back to blog